Louis Carpini Violin Review: A Violin Teacher's Opinion

An Intermediate Violin You Can Start With

The Louis Carpini G2 is considered more of an intermediate violin. But you don’t have to be an intermediate player to play an intermediate violin! A nicer instrument can actually make it easier to learn all the basics, so a beginner could absolutely start learning on this violin.

It also has the capability to handle intermediate and advanced techniques, so you won’t have to worry about outgrowing its capabilities anytime soon.

I got the upgraded Dominant strings and the Giuliani Premier bow, and I definitely recommend both of these upgrades. They allow you to get so much more out of this violin.

Sound and Response

First off, the violin is really lovely. It has a lighter finish and some beautiful flaming on the back.

The thing I noticed immediately when I first played this violin was its response. As soon as I put the bow to the string, I got an immediate, clear, crisp response.

The tone is also more focused than what you’ll find on many beginner violins. It has some brightness, which I love, but it isn’t shrill. It still has warmth and sweetness to it. All of that gives it a more complex tone, with more of that homegrown-rose quality of sound.

If terms like complexity of sound or responsiveness don’t make sense to you yet, check out my video on what you get when you spend more money on a violin.

The extreme ranges of the violin play really well, too. The G string isn’t blatty; it’s full and rich, and it sounds balanced with the other strings. The E string isn’t shrill, either. It’s nice and sweet and resonant.

The Giuliani Premier Bow

I was actually pretty impressed with this little bow. It’s the Giuliani Premier bow, and I was surprised by how much control I was able to get with it. It handles advanced strokes like martele pretty well.

I’m always talking about contact and developing that feel between your fingers, the bow, and the string. This bow lets you develop that skill.

It’s a great bow to start with, but when you’re ready, you could upgrade to a better bow and get even more out of this violin.

One Less Thing for Beginners to Worry About

Another thing I love about this outfit is that it comes with a pre-rosined bow. I got in touch with Kennedy Violins, and they told me that all of their bows included in outfits come pre-rosined.

This might not sound like a huge deal, but it really is helpful.

Brand-new bows require a lot of rosin, and understanding how much rosin a bow needs is a skill that takes time and experience to develop. If you put too much rosin on, you can run into problems. If you don’t put enough on, you may constantly wonder whether the problem is you or the bow.

Add in a brand-new cake of rosin, even if you’ve already scratched up the surface, and it can all combine to make a frustrating experience. Especially if you just want to grab the bow and try out your new violin!

I love that the bows come pre-rosined to the right amount. It’s one less thing you have to figure out as a brand-new beginner.

What I Love Most About the Carpini

I think what I love most about the Carpini is the quality I recognized as soon as I first played it. I love how responsive it is.

I notice this especially when playing pieces like Boccherini or the Minuets from Suzuki. These are light, delicate pieces where a little bit of nuance goes a long way, and the Carpini responds really well to those subtle inputs.

It’s honestly very enjoyable to play.

Who Should Consider the Louis Carpini G2?

When would something in the Louis Carpini price range be a good option for you?

I think adult beginners can definitely benefit from a nicer violin right from the start. Adults tend to have more discerning ears, and I’ve found they usually pick up on variations in sound pretty quickly and begin to understand more advanced techniques relatively soon.

Adults also get frustrated when violins buzz, squeak, and scratch—and who wouldn’t? But when you’re playing on a cheaper violin, sometimes it’s hard to know whether the problem is your technique or the instrument.

With something like the Carpini, you don’t have to worry as much about the violin holding you back. It can help you work on intermediate and advanced techniques without running into the limitations you might find with a less capable instrument.

That’s the main reason to consider a more expensive violin right from the start: you don’t have to worry about outgrowing its capabilities anytime soon.

This violin would also be great for young adults who are making regular progress. And if you play in an orchestra or play for church, the Carpini offers more projection and power than your standard beginner violin.

Geared Pegs and Final Thoughts

I also had Kennedy install geared pegs on this violin, which I absolutely love. Kennedy can install geared pegs on any violin you purchase.

If you want to learn more about the benefits of geared pegs, check out my video comparing VSO pegs, traditional pegs, and geared pegs.

Whether you’re just starting out or looking to upgrade, the Louis Carpini G2 is a great option to consider. I’ll include a link below so you can check the current price and read more in-depth reviews.

Antonio Giuliani Etude Violin Review: A Violin Teacher's Opinion

Antonio Giuliani Etude Violin Review

When it comes to buying a violin, I always recommend buying from a good, reputable string shop that specializes in bowed string instruments. If the store you’re buying from also sells things like soap or salt shakers, you probably want to move on!

I’ve heard a lot of great things about Kennedy Violins from members of Meadowlark Violin Studio who have purchased violins from them, so I was really excited to try out some of their instruments.

I ordered two violins from Kennedy: the Antonio Giuliani Etude and the Louis Carpini G2. For this review, I’ll focus on the Giuliani Etude, but if you want to know more about the Louis Carpini, click here.

A Mid-Range Beginner Violin

The Antonio Giuliani Etude is a mid-range beginner violin. It’s not the absolute cheapest beginner violin, and I think it represents that perfect sweet spot for beginners who want a little more in terms of sound and quality.

Adult beginners will especially do well in this price range because the improved sound offers more for a discerning ear.

This mid-level beginner price range is also great because it allows you to learn more advanced techniques. The quality of the wood and varnish is definitely a step up from your most basic beginner violin, and a huge step up from something like a VSO (violin-shaped object).

A Good Set-Up

When we talk about “set-up” we’re talking about making sure the violin is set-up for success. As in, do the pegs work? Do they turn smoothly? Is the bridge the correct height and curvature? Is the nut height and string spacing correct? Is the sound post set-up optimally? These are all things that should be checked over when a violin is shipped to you and it’s one of those things that you WON’T get when purchasing from a random music store on a site like Amazon.

You want a real luthier to check over all of these little details with set-up, and that’s what you get when ordering from a real violin shop like Kennedy.

All that to say, the basic set-up on the Antonio Giuliani Etude violin was great. No issues there!

Upgraded Strings and Bow

I opted for the upgraded Dominant strings, and that’s an upgrade I do recommend.

As a beginner, you’re probably not going to change your strings during that first year unless you’re playing a lot. Having better strings gives you a better start, with improved sound and response. It just allows you to get more out of the violin.

I also got the upgraded Giuliani Premier bow, and I’m really impressed with this little bow. It actually allows me to do some pretty advanced bow techniques.

One thing I love about this violin and bow combination is that it can handle more weight than your standard beginner violin. That means you can start learning the skill of relaxing more weight into the string.

I’m always telling students to add more weight. This is something beginner students can struggle with when they have a cheaply made violin. If they add more weight, the violin just maxes out and gives up. But the Etude and the Premier bow actually handle quite a bit of weight.

It also has good resonance. You can really hear the violin ring when those third fingers are in tune!

One Less Thing for Beginners to Worry About

Another thing I love about this outfit is that it comes with a pre-rosined bow. I got in touch with Kennedy Violins, and they told me that all of their bows included in outfits come pre-rosined.

This might not sound like a huge deal, but it really is helpful for a beginner.

You don’t have to worry about applying too much rosin with a pre-rosined bow!

Brand-new bows require a lot of rosin, and understanding how much rosin a bow needs is a skill that takes time and experience to develop. If you put too much rosin on, you can run into problems. If you don’t put enough on, you may constantly wonder whether the problem is you or the bow.

Add in a brand-new cake of rosin, even if you’ve already scratched up the surface, and it can all combine to make a frustrating experience. Especially when you just want to grab the bow and try out your new violin!

I love that the bows come pre-rosined to the right amount. It’s just one less thing you have to figure out as a brand-new beginner.

Is the Antonio Giuliani Etude a Good Beginner Violin?

I think this is a great violin for starting out. It will allow you to learn all the beginner and intermediate techniques without feeling like your instrument is holding you back.

Should You Upgrade the Pegs?

The Etude violin comes standard with good, working traditional pegs, but Kennedy Violins can install geared pegs on any violin you purchase. If you’re buying this violin for a child, or if you simply don’t want to deal with the hassle of tuning, geared pegs are an upgrade I highly recommend.

If you want to learn more about the benefits of geared pegs, check out my video comparing VSO pegs, traditional pegs, and geared pegs.

And if you’re curious about what you get when you spend more money on a violin, you might be interested in my review of the Louis Carpini violin or my video about what you get when you spend more money on a violin.

Why Do Some Violins Have Only One Fine Tuner?

Why do some violins have four fine tuners? Why do other violins have only one fine tuner? Do you need to have four fine tuners? Do only beginners have fine tuners?

To understand why some violins have one fine tuner and some have more, we need to discuss a little bit of violin string history.

(Also visit How to Tune a Violin (Without Breaking the Strings!) A Beginner’s Ultimate Guide to Tuning the Violin)

Why Violins Have Fine Tuners

Before the advent of steel strings in the early 1900s, strings were made of gut. Since gut is quite stretchy, fine tuners weren’t necessary. When steel strings came onto the stage in 1919, fine tuners became necessary for violin E strings.

Steel is not as stretchy as gut, therefore it’s much harder to make smaller adjustments with a thin, steel E string. Accidentally over-tightening an E string will make it break. So fine tuners that could make small adjustments became useful for steel E strings.

Fine tuners on violins were pretty handy and it made sense to use them on all the strings for beginner violins to make the tuning process easier for beginners.

Do I Need Four Fine Tuners on My Violin?

You don’t have to have fine tuners on every string. If your pegs work correctly and you don’t have trouble tuning, you can get by with only one fine tuner on the E string. However, there’s no shame in having four fine tuners.

If you have geared pegs on your violin, fine tuners probably aren’t necessary. (It’s still handy to have them on the E string).

Some beginner violins come with tailpieces with four fine tuners built in to the tailpiece. Other violins come with tailpieces that have holes where the strings attach allowing you to add or remove fine tuners to suit your needs.

A Violin with Fine Tuners Built Into the Tailpiece

A violin with REMOVABLE fine tuners and only one fine tuner on the E string

Why do some violins have only one fine tuner?

You will often find that more expensive, higher quality violins often only have one fine tuner on the E string. Usually, more advanced violinists purchase the more expensive violins, so there’s an assumption that the violinist purchasing the violin is comfortable with tuning using the pegs. If the fine tuners aren’t necessary, there’s no need to put them on a violin.

However, you don’t have to be an advanced player to play on an “advanced” violin. Violins that are categorized as “intermediate” or “advanced” are simply more expensive and usually better quality. They don’t require people with advanced skills to play them. On the contrary, high quality violins are much EASIER to play than beginner violins!

So if you’re a beginner and you want to spend the money on a high quality violin, go for it! If you’re worried about having trouble tuning if the violin has only one fine tuner, I recommend getting geared pegs installed. I have geared pegs on my violin and I would never go back to traditional, wooden pegs!

Do Fine Tuners Affect the Sound of a Violin?

Another reason that some violins have only one fine tuner is due to the affect fine tuners can have on the sound. Anytime you add something to a violin, a chinrest, a different tailpiece, it will affect the sound. The more “stuff” you put on a violin, the more potential for buzzes or unwanted noises. If you are comfortable tuning using the pegs, there’s no need for that potential effect on the sound.

Can violinists really tell the difference in sound between a violin with four fine tuners and a violin with one fine tuner? This is hard to say because all of the high quality instruments I’ve ever played have had one fine tuner and all of the cheaper, beginner violins have always had four fine tuners. The cheaper violins didn’t sound cheap because they had four fine tuners, they were simply made from cheaper materials.

I’ve never had a reason to install more fine tuners on my personal violins, so I can’t say if adding fine tuners negatively affects the sound in an obvious manner.

Do Professional Violinists Use Fine Tuners?

If more expensive violins usually come with only one fine tuner, you may be wondering if professional violinists use fine tuners? Many professional violinists don’t use fine tuners (except on the E string). This has to do with aesthetics, the ease of tuning with the pegs, and sound.

However, I’ve seen several famous violinists and fiddlers with more than one fine tuner on their violin. So there is no judgment or shame when it comes to using fine tuners!

To sum it up, if you want to use fine tuners, use them! If you’re a beginner, thinking about purchasing a violin without four fine tuners and wondering if that’s okay, it absolutely is! If you can afford it, I always say go for the nicer, higher quality violin (even if it only has one fine tuner). Get geared pegs installed and you won’t miss the other fine tuners.

Happy Practicing!

Can I Learn Violin on an Electric Violin?

Can Beginners Learn Violin on an Electric Violin?

If you are thinking about learning the violin, you might be wondering “can I learn to play violin on an electric violin?” While you technically could learn violin on an electric violin, I would recommend against beginners starting off with an electric violin. Why? It all has to do with learning to produce a good tone.

Before we get into the specifics about tone, let’s talk about the three types of violins: acoustic, acoustic/electric, and electric.

What is the Difference Between Acoustic Violins, Acoustic/Electric Violins, and Electric Violins?

Acoustic violins have wooden bodies that naturally resonate and amplify the sound. The wooden body of an acoustic violin acts as a resonance chamber. Electric violins don’t have resonance chambers. They require an amplifier in order to be heard. Acoustic/Electric violins have the traditional wooden body, but they also have pick-ups and usually volume adjusters.

Should I start with electric or acoustic violin?

If you are just starting to learn violin, you should start with an acoustic violin. Acoustic violins allow you to hear the tone you are producing and make adjustments. Electric violins require an amplifier to produce a sound. Even then, the amplified sound is not natural and will make it difficult to learn to produce a good tone.

Producing a good tone with the violin is one of the most difficult skills to master. It requires the optimum amount of weight and speed transferred through the bow to the strings. How do you know if you have the right amount of weight and speed? The natural resonance chamber of an acoustic violin will tell you! If something sounds bad, you’ll hear it and be able to adjust. The effects added when playing with an electric violin (such as amplification, distortion, reverb, etc) make it difficult to hear and learn how to produce a good tone. An electric violin without an amplifier is so quiet that you won’t be able to gauge if you are doing the right things with your bow to produce a good tone.

What are the Disadvantages of an Electric Violin?

Electric violins require amplification to be heard, so if you don’t have an amplifier, the electric violin will be very quiet, and may not produce a sound at all. That means you won’t be able to hear everything you need to hear on an electric violin, making it much harder to learn.

The effects of amplification can also distort the natural sound of the violin and hide mistakes with intonation and bowing.

Is Electric Violin Easier than Acoustic Violin?

No! It is much easier to learn to play on an acoustic violin. With an electric violin, it can be difficult if not impossible to learn to produce a good tone. If you are a beginner violinist, you should learn to play on an acoustic violin.

I’m worried about my neighbors. Should I learn to play on an electric violin?

Electric violins are quieter than acoustic violins since they don’t have resonance chambers and rely on amplifiers to produce a sound. An electric violin without an amplifier has a very quiet sound or it may not produce a sound at all. If you are worried about disturbing your neighbors while you learn to play the violin, you can get a practice mute for your acoustic violin which significantly reduces the sound. Beginner violinists should avoid electric violins until you learn the basics of tone production and intonation. The sound of an acoustic violin can be dampened with a practice mute, but you still have the option of removing the practice mute when you’re not worried about disturbing anyone.

I’m worried about being heard when playing with large groups. Should I get an acoustic/electric violin?

A good quality acoustic violin can actually produce a very loud sound once you learn the basics of tone production. If you need to be heard over other louder instruments or in large venues, you can always mic an acoustic violin.

Acoustic/Electric violins are usually more expensive than their counterpart acoustic violins. If you are a beginner, I would recommend putting that extra money towards a better acoustic violin rather than purchasing an acoustic/electric violin. You can always mic an acoustic violin if you need to be louder. If you regularly play at large venues, for large crowds, or with other amplified instruments, then buying an electric violin or an acoustic/electric violin is probably worth the extra money.

Purchasing your first violin can be overwhelming! Do you need more help choosing your first violin? Check out my top 10 violins for beginners.

Happy Practicing!

Buying a Violin For the First Time

Buying your first violin is a big decision. Although it might not involve as much money, it’s something like buying your first house or car. You want something suitable to your needs. Not too cheap, not too expensive. If you are looking for a beginner violin, here are some tips to help you find the perfect one.

You can also check out my top picks for beginner violins here.

How much money do I spend on my first violin?

That’s the question I get asked the most when new students are realizing just how expensive violins can get. Beginner violin outfits will range from $200-$500. Does the more expensive violin actually sound better? Will I progress faster? What about new versus used violins?

Buying Used Violins

Shopping for beginner violins can be similar to shopping for a car. If you buy a used car, you generally get it for cheaper than a new one since you’re accepting dings, scratches, and maybe other unknown problems. With violins, if you buy a used beginner violin (from a reputable source, not Ebay or the thrift store) the first thing you’ll want to do is change the strings (around $40 plus installation) and get the bow re-haired ($40 to $75). When you take those things into account, the used violin might not be cheaper.

Side note: I do have a student who found a very nice violin at a thrift store for $30. Finding jewels like that does happen (never to me!) but it is rare. More often, I see worthless violins at antique stores and thrift shops with outrageous price tags. These violins are usually useful only as wall decorations, so be wary!

Buying New Violins

If you are buying a new violin from a dealer or an online company, how much money is enough? Back to the car analogy. If you are shopping for a new car you have a couple options. You can buy a budget car that gets the job done just fine. But you might only make it to 60,000 miles before problems start creeping up and you either have to pay a lot for repairs, or buy a new car. Instead of purchasing a budget car, you could pay a little more and get a car that will get you past 100,000 miles so you won’t have to worry about buying another car anytime soon.

Good quality “budget” violins will get the job done but you will grow out of them quicker. If you buy a higher end beginner violin or an intermediate violin ($400-$1000) you won’t have to worry about upgrading as soon. Budget violin outfits come with budget bows. Bows on the lower end of the scale can be very heavy or have an annoying wobble when you draw the bow on the string.

You will also be able to do more with a better quality violin. Some of the upgrades you might get are better tuning pegs for easier tuning, a lighter bow or a more stable bow, and better sound production. Learning to produce a good tone on a violin is possibly one of the hardest tasks beginning violinists must overcome. Having good equipment makes it so much easier.

What’s your mission?

Another thing to consider is what you are buying the violin for. If you want to see if you like the violin, then get the budget version or rent. If you will be playing in church or performing, go for something a little nicer. Cheap violins will not project as well when performing. With a better violin, you’ll sound better without having to work so hard. Are you buying a full size violin for a child? Will the child take this violin through high school, orchestra rehearsals, auditions, and the rest of their adult life? Pay a little more. If you’re going on a long road trip, you’d want them to have a good, reliable car, right? You can’t win Nascar races with run-of-the-mill budget cars.

Getting Your Money's Worth

Another question I’m frequently asked is, “If I sell my violin, will I be able to get back what I paid for it?” That’s a very hard question to answer since it depends on what you paid for it, what condition it’s in, where you live, and what the market is like in your area. Keep in mind, beginner violins are not one-of-a-kind Ferraris. They’re more like a basic, stock, Ford Focus. Companies like Shar will be turning out beginner violins until the end of time so if you want to sell your violin, you’ll have to take that into consideration. You wouldn’t buy a new car, put 5,000 miles on it and expect to get exactly what you paid for it. Why? Because your potential buyer could go to the dealer and buy a new car for the same price.

Trade-In Policies

This is the best way to insure you’ll get something out of your old violin. Violin shops often have trade-in policies. If you buy a violin from them and later want to upgrade to a better violin, they will give you money back on your old violin as long as the old violin and the new violin come from their store. Ask your local dealer what their trade-in policy is.

If you are looking for online options, Fiddlershop has a great trade-in policy.

Until you start paying big bucks, violins aren’t really investments. If you take good care of them, they’ll at least hold their value but you probably won’t get more for a beginner violin than what you paid for it. Like other hobbies and activities you do for fun, it’s about the amount of enjoyment you get out of the violin, not how much it will be worth in ten years.

Affording the Better Violin

So you want the better violin, but how do you afford it? Ask your music store what their financing options are. Fiddlershop has a financing option as well as the option to pay in installments.